
Carlie: She's the one they want to win, supposedly, besides the Carrie-clones. Her surprise is that she's a boring homebody. Her voice sounds great on Heart, but, I don't know, I'm bored. She is like the definition of boring.

Sayesha has been in commercials, and she does a damn scary baby-cry imitation. Another yawn-worthy song. "Mr. Jones." The show is making me narcoleptic.

Brooke the nanny is also a freaking Beauty School Dropout. We get to watch her cut some random dude's hair in the bathroom, whippitie woo. What is with the being-able-to-use-instruments thing this year? Brooke doesn't even play the guitar half the time, which is jarring. That said, I think Brooke picked the right song, she just clearly doesn't have remotely the vocal chops that the best women singers have. So, there it is. Cute, but untalented.

Ramiele, my cute little favorite, is a hula dancer. And she's Filipino! OMG, seriously, so are my unborn/unconceived babies! Now you know know I love Ramiele, so that said, meh. Not my fave performance.

Kristy Lee aka Carrie-ette #1 is up next, ready to surprise us: she's a tomboy, that's her surprise. I'm surprised that she's 24 - she looks about 13. Her outfit is straight up frightening. First of all, it's all shiny. Second of all, it's what I used to wear out when I was in college in my black pants silver top phase. Thirdly, it accentuates the Elaine-like nature of her dancing. All that aside, her song is another yawn, a total, energy-less, Carrie Underwood imitation. The judges think it was better than last week. I say, um, that's not difficult.

Dear Lord, next up is Amanda Obermeyer. I find this person totally frightening. She is also a bookworm. She's one of those "knowledge is powerful" people, and realizes you can always be more educated. She educates herself by reading biographies of rock stars. She says this all totally earnestly. She butchers an amazing song with both her singing and her absolutely freakish dancing. It's like watching drunk, mid-western karaoke, but worse. Honestly, the judges were wildly kind.

Alaina Whitaker up next, officially making this the Carrie-fest it is. The most interesting thing about this clone is that she doesn't like her foods to touch. What a cultural icon. Alaina is trying out for her high school musical with Hopelessly Devoted to You. As a nice touch she wore her prom dress. It was a high school quality performance.

Cut little Alexandréa is up. Her big surprise is that she's basically already a star and sang at Ground Zero. More Disney-fication. I absolutely love the song she chose: Peter Cetera, Baby Please Don't Go. It was staid, and the outfit was a little weird, but she has a very nice voice. Randy is right (God help me): she picked a safe, boring choice. One thing I like about her: she always puts her own original stamp on a song.

Our third Carrie-ette, Kady, sings opera!? She is one of those annoying people that sings opera in the shower and wakes everyone up. Now, I think Kady has the most presence out of all the Underwood-ettes, and I really like her dress. Bad song, though. Don't sing Heart when someone else with an amazing voice (cough, the first girl), sings Heart.

Asia'h is a cheerleader, and she's kind of a hottie! But girl must be kind of sick or something, because she was just meh this week. There's too big a contrast between her chest voice and her head voice. She's in trouble, and you can see the fear in her eyes.
The long and short is, none of them are great. I have totally forgotten the episode, except for Amanda Obermeyer's performance, which will live in my deepest, most frightening subconscious forever.